“We Reserve The Right To Refuse Service To Anyone”, But What Would Blackstone Do?

“The common law of England, so far as it is not repugnant to or in conflict with the Constitution and laws of the United States, or the Constitution and laws of this State, shall be the rule of decision in all the courts of this State.” NRS 1.030. I’ve previously written about how both California

How To Revive A Suspended Corporation

Yesterday’s post concerned the circumstances that will cause the California Franchise Tax Board to suspend a corporation’s rights, powers, and privileges to conduct business in California.  Suspension, however, is reversible, although it isn’t necessarily easy.  First, is the matter of delinquent returns.  The Franchise Tax Board requires that all delinquent tax returns be filed.  Second,

Suspension By The Franchise Tax Board

Yesterday’s post concerned the two circumstances in which the Secretary of State might suspend a corporation.  The California Franchise Tax Board will suspend a corporation if it fails to pay taxes, penalties, fees or interest (Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code § 23301) or fails to file a return (Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code § 23301.5). These

Corporate Suspension By The California Secretary Of State

In California, a corporation may find its powers, rights and privileges suspended by either the Secretary of State or by the Franchise Tax Board.  Today’s post discusses the two roads to suspension by the California Secretary of State. The most common cause for suspension is the failure to file the annual information statement required by Corporations Code Section 1502

Court Rules Attorney-Client Privilege Ceases To Exist When Corporation Ceases To Exist Without Successor

The LLC May Well Be The Platypus Of Business Organizations What happens to the attorney-client privilege when a corporation dissolves?  Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim recently answered that question in Virtue Global Holdings Ltd. v. Rearden LLC, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 53076 (N.D. Cal. April 5, 2016): When a corporation ceases to exist, “the corporate powers, rights and

Unilateral Disarmament, The Prisoners’ Dilemma And SEC Staff Comment Letters

In an arms race, each suffers the worst result if it disarms and the other side remains armed.  However, if both sides are armed, they are not as well off as when both sides are disarmed.  This is, of course, the classic “Prisoners’ Dilemma” game (see table below). Much the same logic applies to the SEC’s insistence

Has Your Promissory Note Been Outlawed?

The modern understanding of the term “outlaw” is someone who has broken the law and has not been captured and brought to justice.  There is, however, another sense of the term.  A note is said to be “outlawed” when the statute of limitations no longer permits its enforcement.  Fleury v. Ramacciotti, 8 Cal. 2d 660,

Is Forced Speech In Responding To Staff Comment Letters Inaccurate Speech?

In 2014, the Securities and Exchange Commission announced that all comment letters would request that the issuer include the so-called “Tandy Letter”.  Thus, all staff comment letters include a request for a written statement in haec verba: The company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing; Staff comments or

Simple Majority Voting And The Magna Carta

Some activists are continuing to submit stockholder proposals seeking the implementation of “simple majority voting”.  For example,  Morgan Stanley’s 2016 proxy statement includes the following proposal from Newground Social Investment, SPC: RESOLVED: Shareholders of Morgan Stanley hereby request the Board to take or initiate the steps necessary to amend the Company’s governing documents to provide that all non-binding matters presented

Why Delaware Corporations Should Worry About California Law When Making Dividends

When paying a dividend to shareholders, California corporations are subject to Chapter 5 of the California Corporations Code.  Corporations incorporated in Delaware and other states may also be subject to Chapter 5 if they meet the conditions of Corporations Code Section 2115, California’s pseudo-foreign corporation statute.  Section 2115 excepts companies with outstanding companies listed on